| Questions | Question 1 | Question 2 | Question 3 | Question 4 | Question 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Decision to be made (Phrased as a question.): |
Is there a particular order in which certain measures are
authorized before others? |
During inclement weather should aircraft be spaced more closely
together or farther apart? |
What aircraft maneuvers or speed changes can be ordered to
slow the incoming air traffic? |
What other dynamics are involved in air traffic flow control? |
Is it preferrable to simply re-route aircraft to another nearby
airport that is unaffected by the inclement weather? |
| B. Critical Factors Involved |
air speed miles-in-trail spacing coordination with approach control and center control and local control ATM regulations flow control center of operations |
air speed miles-in-trail spacing coordination with approach control ATM regulations
|
re-routing traffic en route to slow air flow miles-in-trail spacing call for release coordination with approach contro
|
ground stop operations coordination with approach control and center controllers ATM regulations weather conditions throughout the United States flow control center of operations |
cost effectiveness for airline operations coordination with approach control and other nearby local controllers ATM regulations |
| C. Information known |
Weather at the airport has deteriorated because of thunderstorm activity.
You are requested by the approach control and tower to reduce the arrival
rate to 30 per hour. |
Separation regulations: Laterally -- 5 miles; Vertically -- 1,000 feet (if the aircraft is below 29,000 feet) 2,000 feet (if the aircraft is at 29,000 feet or above) The controllers can accomplish this separation by issuing instructions
to the pilots of the aircraft involved. Altitude assignments, speed adjustments,
and radar vectors are examples of instructions that might be issued to
aircraft. |
circling maneuvers, holding patterns and "S" flight maneuvers
|
|
|
| D. Information
needed (question) |
What are the measures or options commonly used for reducing
the incoming lines of air traffic? |
What are the FAA regulations for spacing of aircraft during
inclement weather? |
What are the re-routing and maneuver options? |
How does the flow control at Herndon, VA keep air traffic
moving smoothly despite regions with severe weather? |
Is re-routing to a different destination airport a top consideration? |
| E. Resources
for fact-finding |
ATM Tutorial FAA web site Safe Separation Standards |
ATM Tutorial FAA web site miles-in-trail spacing |
ATM Tutorial FAA web site call for release |
ATM Tutorial FAA web site ground stop operations |
ATM Tutorial FAA web site |
| F. Answers to each question |
A variety of options are used to change the flow of air traffic without
completely disrupting the system:1) increase spacing between aircraft
by slowing the speed of each aircraft; 2) request that aircraft perform
an "S" maneuver (a curved zigzag) that will serve to elongate
their flight route and slow their arrival time to the detsination airport;
3) make an alternation in their course by having each aircraft follow
a certain vector for awhile before resuming course toward airport; 4)
Hold all aircraft that are scheduled for the affected destination airport
that have yet to take off until inclement weather has passed or until
traffic line has been reduced and regulated. 5) Have aircraft in the arrival
phase assume a holding pattern high above the destination airport and
the inclement weather until the arrrival rate has been appropriately adjusted
and they can be placed in line to descend for approach. |
During inclement weather aircraft are spaced farther apart. |
A variety of options are used to change the flow of air traffic
without completely disrupting the system: 1) increase spacing between aircraft
by slowing the speed of each aircraft; 2) request that aircraft perform
an "S" maneuver (a curved zigzag) that will serve to elongate
their flight route and slow their arrival time to the detsination airport;
3) make an alternation in their course by having each aircraft follow a
certain vector for awhile before resuming course toward airport; 4) Hold
all aircraft that are scheduled for the affected destination airport that
have yet to take off until inclement weather has passed or until traffic
line has been reduced and regulated. 5) Have aircraft in the arrival phase
assume a holding pattern high above the destination airport and the inclement
weather until the arrrival rate has been appropriately adjusted and they
can be placed in line to descend for approach. |
Flow Control monitors the "big picture" for weather changes
and "high traffic times" at all airports. Because they can make
fairly accurate predictions of weather changes, they can look ahead and
re-route traffic around "bad" weather spots and with some accuracy
forecast an appropriate airport closure time thus allowing time and consideration
for re-routing traffic to another airport. Traffic flow procedures are
used dynamically and are approved by the Air Traffic Control System Command
Center (Central Flow), located in Herndon, VA. |
No, it is preferred that all other measures be implemented first before
simply re-routing to a different airport. Re-routing an aircraft to a
completely different airport costs the airlines too much revenue as these
airplane passengers will usually have to be bussed to their intended destination
or have to have major changes made in their ticketing and itineraries,
which is costly in personnel time to make these changes. |
| A. Possible Decisions | B. Negative Consequences |
B. Positive Consequences |
C. Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|
|
First, the center will impose Miles-in-Trail (MIT) spacing on all arrival
routes. Controllers will start vectoring aircraft under their control
to increase spacing. Initial, MIT will be 7 to 10 miles and will be increased,
as the aircraft numbers in the airspace are reduced, to 15 to 20 miles.
When it is determined that Expanded Miles-in-Trail conditions are required,
adjacent centers are asked to provide 20 MIT. |
Slows air traffic farther out from airport and causes flight delays throughout
the region. Increases fuel consumption. |
Immediately begins to contain the situation at the affected airport and
maintains a high level of safety for aircraft flying into the airport. |
|
|
Second, in conjunction with MIT provisions, the center will have all
aircraft entering the approach control airspace at reduced speeds. Normally,
jets will enter approach controls airspace at or above 250 knots,
depending on the altitude the arrival is required to cross the arrival
fix. When flow to the airport is reduced, jets will be required to enter
the approach control airspace at speeds of less than 250 knots. |
Slows air traffic farther out from airport and causes flight delays throughout
the region. |
Immediately begins to contain the situation at the affected airport and
makes flying into the airport safer. Slower speeds reduce fuel consumption.
|
|
|
Third, all aircraft within the centers airspace landing at the
airport with the reduced rate would be placed in a Call for Release (CFR)
category. This provides the center traffic management unit the ability
to fit these flights in when spacing becomes available. |
Increases the amount of delays per other airports, yet provides flexibility
for controllers to fit in aircraft when appropriate to move air traffic
flow along a certain route. |
Provides flexibility for controllers to fit in aircraft when appropriate
to move air traffic flow along a certain route. |
|
|
Fourth, the center will initiate Re-Routes to have flights fly additional
miles to increase spacing. Re-Routes are used to off load arrival routes
with heavy traffic volume to other arrival routes not as busy. |
Slows air traffic farther out from airport and causes flight delays throughout
the region. Increases fuel consumption for the airlines. |
Immediately decreases air traffic flow to that area and evens out the
air traffgic flow within and around that region, thus increasing safety. |
|
|
Fifth, if the reduce rate continues for more than a certain amount of
time based on the schedule for the airport, Ground Stop (GS) procedures
are put into effect, which apply to the whole country. |
Halts all aircraft before they takeoff from distant airports with this
airport scheduled as their destination airport. Increases the amount of
delayed flights immediately. Increases the amount of people, baggage and
aircraft at the many departure airports, which could delay other incoming
aircraft at the gates. |
Cost effective measure for airlines in that they will not have aircraft
burning fuel in elongated flight or holding patterns, instead the aircraft
remain on the ground until they are able to fly directly and safely to
that airport. |
|
|
Note: All of the above traffic flow procedures are used dynamically and
are approved by the Air Traffic Control System Command Center (Central
Flow), located in Herndon, VA. |
|
|
| Final decision with rationale: TOP 3 CHOICES | First Choice: | Second choice: | Third Choice: | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reflect upon decision: |
|
|
|
|